A face familiar to CBS soap fans moved to Salem when Linsey Godfrey joined the cast of DAYS OF OUR LIVES as Sarah Horton in October 2018. The actress previously played Caroline Spencer on THE BOLD & THE BEAUTIFUL from 2012-18, earning three Daytime Emmy Award nominations for her work over the years. “What a lucky birthday girl I am!” she enthused on Instagram when news of her casting on the NBC sudser broke. “I’m so excited and honored to announce I’ve joined the amazing cast of DAYS!” The character of Sarah Horton has been played by numerous actresses since her birth in 1981, including child stars, but Lisa Brinegar and Aimee Brooks played the role for the longest stints.
Maggie Horton had agreed to act as a surrogate for an anonymous donor, so Sarah was conceived through artificial insemination. While it was originally believed that Evan Whyland was her father, it was later revealed that the babydaddy was actually Dr. Neil Curtis, who had performed the procedure! Although Sarah will always consider Mickey Horton to be her dad because he was the man who actually raised her after he and Maggie won the custody battle.
Sarah was hit by a car when Eve Donovan was driving drunk, and after her recovery, noticed that Mickey wasn’t around as much because he was working more. Sarah was shocked to learn that Maggie was having an affair with Neil and caught them in bed together. The young woman wanted to expose her to Micky, but Maggie revealed that Neil was her biological father. Sarah still told Micky about the affair, but thankfully, he and Maggie were able to work things out. In 1991, Sarah left town with her sister, Melissa, and they settled in Nashville.
Sarah returned home to her mother in Salem after working with Doctors Without Borders to share some great news. She and Rex Brady were engaged to be married! Unfortunately, she kicked Rex to the curb when she found out that Mimi Lockhart’s baby was actually his. Things got even worse when Rex also confessed to having slept with her sister, Noelle! Looking for revenge, Sarah threw herself at Rex’s brother, Eric Brady, but he turned her down. Drunk, she slept with Xander Kiriakis and immediately regretted it.
Rex managed to win Sarah back and they even walked down the aisle, but they ultimately split up as she was still in love with Eric. But then she had to break things off with Eric once his ex, Nicole Walker, came home not as dead as everyone had thought! Unfortunately, Sarah discovered that she was pregnant with Eric’s baby and tried to hide the truth from him. When Xander learned about it, she swore him to secrecy and he even accompanied her to get an abortion. But in the end, she didn’t go through with it and planned to leave town. But Eric found out about the baby and begged her to stay in Salem.
After a year passed in the blink of an eye, Sarah had given birth and Xander was claiming to be Mackenzie’s father to keep Eric from the truth. But Nicole told Eric about his daughter, and when Mickey had neuroblastoma, he went with Sarah to Boston so the infant could be treated. But what Sarah and Eric didn’t realize was that Mickey wasn’t their child at all. When Sarah had gone into labor, Adrienne Kiriakis was driving her to the hospital when they were run off the road by a drunk Maggie. Xander helped Sarah give birth and rushed them to the hospital, but the newborn died of complications. Desperate, Xander plotted with Victor Kiriakis to have the doctor switch Sarah and Eric’s baby with Kristen DiMera and Brady Black‘s healthy newborn.
When Mickey required a bone marrow transplant, Gabi Hernandez was the only match and was pressured into being the donor and saving the little girl’s life. Xander popped the question and Sarah accepted, not realizing what he had done. Nicole discovered the truth and despite Xander’s best efforts, it came out. Heartbroken, Sarah dumped Xander and ran away to Paris with Mackenzie but ultimately agreed to return the little girl to Kristen and Brady.
Xander continued trying to make amends with Sarah and while she pushed him away for a while, she ultimately found herself unable to resist her feelings. She warned him not to go back to his evil scheming ways, but then found herself helping him spy on Philip Kiriakis to find out what he was hiding. The two made such a great pair that they even proposed to each other at the same time!
Stay tuned to see what happens next!